People Also Ask Just Went 97% AI. Here Is What It Actually Costs You
By David Sessford · 10 Sep 2026 · 8 min read
- People Also Ask answers hit 97% AI generated in the first week of September 2026, up from roughly 12% fourteen months earlier.
- Google is now building simple tools directly into AI Overviews, starting with a character counter. Commodity utility pages are exposed.
- AI Mode is testing paginated follow up questions, on top of AI Overviews already expanding into full AI Mode answers by default.
- Apple confirmed that Applebot-Extended site rules are not considered in ranking for Apple Search, so you can opt out of AI training without a ranking penalty.
- ChatGPT Ads is now self serve in 52 countries and reportedly hit a $1 billion annualised run rate in under 200 days.
- Google Merchant Center added AI Search intent, AI Search terms and AI attributes, giving retailers real AI query data for the first time.
Here is the number that should have ruined your Wednesday. In the first week of September 2026, 97% of People Also Ask answers on Google were AI generated. Fourteen months ago that figure was 12%.
That is not a wobble. That is a whole SERP feature changing owner while most SEOs were arguing about title tags.
This is your AI search roundup for the week of 8 September 2026. Every number below is sourced. Where the data is thin, I say so.
People Also Ask went 97% AI. Here is the actual data
Two independent datasets landed on the same conclusion this week.
Saeed Khosravi at Allintitle posted that his Also Ask Miner data shows Google's People Also Ask answers have been 100% AI generated since August 2026. Barry Schwartz then asked Mark Williams-Cook at AlsoAsked to check it against a bigger sample. AlsoAsked pulled 19.2 million English language PAA results from 2026. The answer: 97% in the first week of September, up from 86% in August. Williams-Cook added that it seems "highly likely we are on track for 100% shortly".
Fourteen months ago, AlsoAsked measured the same thing at roughly 12%.
| When | Share of PAA answers that are AI Overviews | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Roughly July 2025 | 12% | AlsoAsked |
| August 2026 | 86% | AlsoAsked (19.2M sample) |
| First week of September 2026 | 97% | AlsoAsked (19.2M sample) |
| From August 2026 | 100% | Allintitle Also Ask Miner |
Take the conservative figure. 97% is still a takeover.
Why this matters more than it looks
People Also Ask used to be a free ride. You wrote a clean question and answer block, Google lifted it into the PAA box, and it carried your link. Plenty of small sites built a real traffic habit on that one trick.
Now the box answers the question itself and labels it as an AI Overview. Your content still feeds it. Your link is now a citation, not a destination. Same work, different payout.
So the play changes. You are no longer writing to be lifted into a box with a blue link attached. You are writing to be the source the machine names. Different target, different structure, different measurement. We walk through this exact rewrite, block by block, inside the Dojo.
Google is now building the tool instead of linking to it
Second story of the week, and it is a warning shot at an entire category of website.
Google has started showing an interactive character counter widget inside AI Overviews. Search for a character counter and you get a working character counter, in the results, for free. You do not need the seventeen ad stuffed tool sites that were ranking for that term.
If your business model is "a free calculator wrapped in display ads", you have been on notice for a while. This week the notice got specific. Google has already done this with unit conversion, timers, colour pickers and password generators. Character counting is just the newest scalp.
The lesson is not "tools are dead". The lesson is that a commodity utility is not a moat. If a model can rebuild your entire value proposition in a widget, it will. What it cannot rebuild is judgment, proof, and a named human who has actually done the thing.
AI Mode keeps quietly eating the rest of the page
Two more AI Mode moves this week, both small on their own, both pointing the same direction.
Google is testing paginated follow up questions and responses inside AI Mode, with a skip button. Ask a thing, get an answer, get served the next question before you have thought of it. That is a chat product wearing a search product's clothes.
This sits on top of the change Google confirmed at the end of August, where AI Overviews now dynamically expand into a full AI Mode style answer by default on some queries, with the "Ask anything" box already open and no "Show more" button to click. Google's line was that this only happens "for topics where our systems determine it is most useful for people", and that the expansion cancels if you have already started scrolling.
Read those two together. Google is not adding an AI layer to search. Google is turning search into a conversation and leaving the ten blue links underneath as a footnote. If you want the mechanics of getting quoted in that surface, our AI Overviews playbook and the content chunking guide cover the two moves that matter most.
Apple said the quiet part out loud on Applebot Extended
Apple updated its Applebot documentation over the weekend and added one line: "Site rules for Applebot-Extended are not considered in ranking for Search."
Translation: blocking Apple from using your content to train its models will not hurt you in Apple's search results. It is the same separation Google drew between Googlebot and Google-Extended.
That is a useful clarification, because the fear of being punished for opting out is what has kept a lot of publishers from opting out at all. Now you have it in writing from Apple. Whether you should block it is a different question, and the honest answer is that it depends on whether you want to be in Apple's AI answers later. There is no public data yet on how much traffic Apple Intelligence citations actually send. Anyone quoting you a number on that is guessing.
If you want to audit which crawlers you are letting in and which you are shutting out, the checklist in our crawler blocking guide is the fastest way to do it without accidentally walling yourself out of ChatGPT.
OpenAI's ad machine is now a real business
The commercial story of the week. Search Engine Land reported that OpenAI has expanded ChatGPT Ads into more markets, with the help centre listing 52 countries with self service Ads Manager access as of 3 September 2026, spanning North America, most of Europe, the Gulf, North Africa, India, Japan, Korea, Australia and New Zealand.
Alongside that came a batch of ad stack upgrades: better custom audience management (add, remove or replace members without rebuilding), mixed identifier types in one request, and audiences above five million members. Plus new conversion measurement, pacing and reporting.
And the number everyone will repeat: ChatGPT Ads reportedly hit a $1 billion annualised revenue run rate in under 200 days.
Here is why you should care even if you never buy a ChatGPT ad. Once an answer engine has an ad business, the organic answer becomes inventory. Everything you know about how Google's SERP got squeezed over twenty years is about to happen to AI answers in a fraction of the time. The free window is open now. It will not be this open in 2028.
Retailers finally get AI search terms data
Quietly the most practical thing that happened all week. Google Merchant Center's AI Performance Insights report, which launched in July and has been expanding to more regions this month, has gained three new dimensions: AI Search intent, AI Search terms and AI attributes.
Actual query level visibility into what people are asking AI surfaces before they land on your products. For anyone selling physical goods, that is the first time you can plan AI search content off real data instead of vibes.
Pair that with the AI Mode data Google switched on in Search Console last week and you finally have two measurement surfaces instead of zero. This is the bit agencies charge $2k a month to "interpret" for you. It is a report. You can read a report.
Everything else that moved this week
| What happened | Why it matters | Date |
|---|---|---|
| Google says EU DMA changes caused the largest reduction in search quality it has seen | European SERPs are being rebuilt to avoid fines. Expect volatility if you have EU traffic | 8 Sep |
| OpenAI shipped ChatGPT Images 2.5 | A serious image editor inside the biggest AI surface. More reason people never leave the chat | 8 Sep |
| Gemini's Daily Brief went free in the US | Google pushing Gemini into daily habit territory, not just query territory | 8 Sep |
| Google Shopping ads showing a reverse crocodile effect with AI Overviews | Impressions and clicks moving together for shopping ads, unlike organic. Paid is being protected | 7 Sep |
| Google published docs on regional differences in the search experience | Useful if you operate across markets and cannot work out why your SERP looks different | 9 Sep |
| John Mueller warned again that low value programmatic SEO makes Google lose faith in a site | Scaled AI pages are still the fastest way to poison a domain | 7 Sep |
| Search Console had a short indexing reporting glitch, since confirmed as a blip | If your pages showed as Crawled, currently not indexed on 8 Sep, it was not you | 9 Sep |
What to actually do about it this week
No theory. Five moves, in order.
- Stop optimising for the PAA box. Start optimising to be the cited source. Find your pages that used to win PAA. Rewrite the top of each one as a single clean 40 to 60 word answer directly under the question as a heading. That block is what gets lifted.
- Audit your tool pages. If you have a free calculator or converter driving traffic, assume Google will build it. Add the thing a widget cannot copy: worked examples, real numbers, an opinion, a named author.
- Check your crawler rules. Apple has now confirmed Applebot-Extended rules do not affect Apple Search ranking, so decide deliberately rather than by accident. While you are in there, make sure you have not blocked GPTBot or OAI-SearchBot by copy pasting someone's robots.txt.
- If you sell products, open Merchant Center. Pull the new AI Search terms report. Write against what it says, not what you assume.
- Get third party mentions moving. The models trust what other sites say about you far more than what you say about yourself. That has not changed all year and it is still the thing almost nobody does.
If you want the full system behind those five moves, with the templates, the tracker and the exact page structure that gets lifted, that is what the Dojo is. If you would rather we just did it, Done For You exists for that. And the tools we actually use are listed in the Armory.
The 2027 view
Here is the honest read. PAA hitting 97% is not the story on its own. The story is the pattern.
Google is answering questions itself. Google is building the tools itself. Google is turning the results page into a conversation. OpenAI is building an ad business on top of its answers. Every one of those moves shortens the distance between a person's question and a finished answer, and every one of them cuts a link out of the middle.
The businesses that win the next eighteen months are not the ones with the most pages. They are the ones the machine names. That means being an entity with a clear identity, being talked about on sources the models already trust, and putting a clean answer at the top of every page you own.
It is not complicated. It is just that almost nobody is doing it while there is still room. That is the whole opportunity.
Join The Dojo
Every move in this roundup, turned into a step by step system, with the templates and the tracker. No agency retainer. Join The Dojo. $67/mo.
Frequently asked questions
Is People Also Ask really 100% AI now?
Not quite, depending on whose data you use. Allintitle's Also Ask Miner reported 100% AI generated PAA answers from August 2026. AlsoAsked, using a 19.2 million result sample, measured 97% in the first week of September 2026, up from 86% in August. Both agree the direction is the same.
Does People Also Ask still send traffic?
Less than it did, and the mechanism has changed. The answers are now AI Overviews, so your content is being used as a cited source rather than being lifted with a prominent link. Some citation clicks still land, but you should measure it rather than assume it.
Should I stop writing FAQ sections on my pages?
No. Keep them, but change the purpose. A clean question and a 40 to 60 word answer is still the format AI systems lift most reliably. You are writing to be quoted and cited now, not to win a blue link inside a PAA box.
Will blocking Applebot Extended hurt my Google rankings?
No. Applebot-Extended is Apple's crawler, not Google's, so it has no bearing on Google. Apple has now also confirmed in its own documentation that Applebot-Extended site rules are not considered in ranking for Apple Search.
What is the new Merchant Center AI Search terms report?
It is a set of new dimensions added to Google Merchant Center's AI Performance Insights report in September 2026, covering AI Search intent, AI Search terms and AI attributes. It gives retailers query level visibility into AI driven product discovery.
Are ChatGPT ads going to push organic citations out?
There is no public data proving that yet, so treat anyone claiming otherwise with suspicion. What we do know is that ChatGPT Ads is now live in 52 countries for self service and reportedly reached a $1 billion annualised run rate in under 200 days. Once an answer surface monetises, commercial pressure on organic placement historically follows.
What is the single most useful change to make this week?
Rewrite the top of your best pages as a single clean answer block directly under the question as a heading. It is the cheapest change on the list and it is the format every AI answer surface lifts from.
David Sessford. Founder of The KillerEdge, 14+ years in SEO & online marketing More about the founders →
Sources
- Search Engine Roundtable: Almost 100% Of People Also Ask Results Are Answered By Google AI Overviews
- Search Engine Roundtable: Google AI Overviews Get A Character Counter Tool
- Search Engine Roundtable: Google AI Mode Tests Paginated Follow Up Responses With Skip Button
- Search Engine Roundtable: Google AI Overviews Pushing Searchers Into AI Mode
- Search Engine Roundtable: Site Rules For Applebot-Extended Are Not Considered In Ranking For Search
- Search Engine Roundtable: Google Merchant Center AI Performance Insights
- Search Engine Land: OpenAI expands ChatGPT ads globally and builds out its ad stack
- Search Engine Roundtable: Google Says EU DMA Changes Resulted In Largest Reduction In Search Quality
- Search Engine Roundtable: Google Shopping Ads Have A Reverse Crocodile Effect With AI Overviews
- Search Engine Roundtable: Google Can Lose Faith In Sites Based On Low Value Programmatic SEO
- Search Engine Roundtable: Daily Search Forum Recap, September 9 2026
- OpenAI: Introducing ChatGPT Images 2.5
Grab the free AI-Search Cheat Sheet
The exact moves to make ChatGPT, Gemini and Google AI name-drop YOU. Plus the weekly intel. Free.
Instant download. No spam. Quit anytime.
Want this done for you?
I run SEO, link building, lead generation and ads for businesses like yours. One operator, no lock-in.
Get a free plan → ← Back to the blog